Scopes Trial Courthouse - Dayton, TN.jpg

neuroscience

Kant Confessed His Suspicions about the Limitations of His System, but Persisted Anyway

Immanuel Kant

It is a mark of courage or at least bold if not heroic confidence that Kant forged ahead with his attempt to describe the mechanisms and functions of human cognition, even though he suspected that some of the descriptive ideas he invented would probably never be scientifically verified.

In a section of the Critique of Pure Reason, titled “The Schematism of the Pure Concepts of the Understanding” (chapter 1 of book 2 of the “Transcendental Analytic”) he wrote:

This schematism of our understanding, in its application to appearances and their mere form, is an art concealed in the depths of the human soul, whose real modes of activity nature is hardly likely ever to allow us to discover, and to have open to our gaze.

Preceding this pessimistic observation, Kant had been explaining his hypothesized “schema” as rules for how to conjoin or link an a priori concept that is not dependent on sensual experience with an object of perception obtained through the senses. He uses several examples to illustrate. With the example of a triangle he asserts that associating the concept of triangle with an empirically apprehend image of a triangle is effected by means of set of innate rules or instructions that he calls a schema. A “schematism” according to Kant is an application of a set of rules whereby a pure, a priori concept of understanding such as space, time, triangle, or number is correlated with an empirically constituted object or idea.

But in the interjected “aside” to the reader quoted above, Kant expresses his suspicion that “nature is hardly likely ever to allow us to discover” the “real modes of activity” that constitute the functioning of those schema, or rules for linking the inner, mental world of pure concepts with sensibly perceived objects or empirically derived ideas.

Kant may have been trying with his schema — sets of rules for linking a priori concepts with sensually perceived objects — to (among other things) heal the body/mind split of Descartes. If Kant was right about “nature” being likely to never allow us to “gaze” upon schema, then neuroscientists who today address the hard problem of consciousness by mapping the areas of the brain that correlate with subjectively reported states of consciousness (qualia), observed behavior, or visible correlates of autonomic nerve activity, these neuroscientists may then, like Kant, worry that they too will likely never succeed in actually “gazing” on the mechanisms (schema, rules) that link inner consciousness experience with the exterior world of things.

More than 230 years following the publication of Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason, many philosophers and cognitive scientists working with or following the ideas of philosophers like Daniel Dennett, prefer not to invent and use terms or ideas like Kant’s “schema” — the hypothesized (invisible, postulated, unverifiable) rules for how we link or associate inner concepts with perceived objects. They avoid and argue against using scientifically unverifiable ideas or hypotheses. They, like Dennett, will for the sake of argument deign to take up for discussion ideas that are not susceptible to empirical proof (cf. the ether and phlogiston hypotheses), but then, after discussing and exposing their vacuousness and unusability, summarily drop them, and urge others to do the same.

Daniel Dennett

Knowing what terms or ideas to avoid using in attempting scientifically to solve the riddle and mystery of consciousness is important. Knowing what not to do or think is progress. But the hard problem of consciousness (what is like to be somethingqualiaJohn Searle’s Chinese roomMary the color-blind super scientist) is still unsolved. Notwithstanding his occasional use of non-verifiable ideas like “schema” and “schematism,” Kant’s attempts in the Critique to heal the mind-body split deduced by René Descarte in his Meditations, argue against the empirical skepticism expressed by David Hume in his Treatise and Enquiry, and correct or balance the radical empiricism of John Locke’s Essay surely contain many useable ideas that can be “operationalized” by neuroscientists, cognitive researchers, and philosophers of consciousness in their attempt to solve, understand, and explain the “hard problem” of consciousness.

Robert Paul Wolff

Robert Paul Wolff

A book published many years ago by Robert Paul Wolff, Kant’s Theory of Mental Activity: A Commentary on the Transcendental Analytic of the Critique of Pure Reason (Harvard University Press, 1963; Kindle [Society for Philosophy and Culture, 2013]) is the best commentary I have yet read on Kant’s Critique. Wolff has also recorded and published on YouTube a very helpful nine-part lecture series on the Critique.

 

Share
Calendar
May 2019
M T W T F S S
« Oct    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  
Archives
Politics, Culture, Philosophy
  • Rachel Maddow
  • Frank Schaeffer
  • Roberto Ruiz

Freedom Caucus condemns its own member over impeachment assessmentIn 2015, the House Freedom Caucus was a reactionary thorn in the Republican establishment's sid [...]

Trump contradicts his allies' claims on Iran, security threatsIn reference to Iranian aggression, Trump said he's seen "no indication that anything has [...]

Trying to keep Trump's finances secret, his lawyers fail miserablyTrump's lawyers failed miserably to block a subpoena sent to his accounting firm. The president [...]

Did Team Trump direct Michael Cohen to lie to Congress?We've reached the point at which Trump World lawyers themselves have been accused of possibly c [...]

New White House stonewalling intensifies impeachment pushThe former White House counsel may be able to shed light on Trump alleged crimes, but Trump is silen [...]

Nadler calls out White House, DOJ for specious legal argumentRachel Maddow talks with Lawrence O'Donnell about the Trump administration's effort to bol [...]

Extreme anti-abortion laws spark reproductive rights protestsDr. Leana Wen, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood, talks with Rachel Maddow about how American [...]

Trump court loss a crack in wall hiding Trump financesRep. Adam Schiff talks with Rachel Maddow about the need to follow Donald Trump's money where R [...]

Cohen transcript puts spotlight on Trump Tower Moscow deceptionRep. Adam Schiff talks with Rachel Maddow about themes in the transcript of Michael Cohen's tes [...]

Trump tactics to conceal his finances begin to fall apartRachel Maddow highlights reporting in the New York Times about suspicious activity reports prepared [...]

The last time I saw Mark Zuckerberg was in the summer of 2017, several months before the Cambridge A [...]

“Biden and Sanders come across as romantics. Biden- stuck in the past, when real bipartisanship some [...]

The woman who blew open the Cambridge Analytica scandal says Mark Zuckerberg and Jack Dorsey are ‘ha [...]

It’s very early in the race to 2020, and there are a lot of wonderful candidates on the Democratic s [...]

Trump, Assange, Bannon, Farage… bound together in an unholy allianceby Carole Cadwalladr The WikiLea [...]

Watch this! You won’t find a more compelling argument today for the need for human decency, being ki [...]

It seems fantastical that a 37-year-old openly gay mayor from South Bend can even be in this convers [...]

Pete Buttigieg has a long-term generational view. He is not reacting to the media outrage cycle of t [...]

Maria Ressa, chief of Philippine news site Rappler, was released on bail after being arrested at an [...]

THE MUELLER REPORT DID NOT EXONERATE TRUMP OF Self-dealing Trump family corruption Cheating on taxes [...]

After having been unjustly convicted of the bogus charges brought against him in that most infamous [...]

The Philosophy of Christopher NolanEver since I first watched Memento and its fascinating exploration of the philosophical question of [...]

Voltaire - CandideThe philosophical problem of evil—the question of how the existence of unnecessary suffering is poss [...]

Arrow - A Celebration of LoveLife is hard enough as it is. Existence, in many ways, is suffering. Obviously, some have it much wo [...]

If 'Despacito' Were Written by an Evo-Devo BiologistIf you are a geek, you are likely to get excited over things others might find boring, laughable, la [...]

James Baldwin Debates William F. BuckleyJames Baldwin, the great essayist, poet, civil rights activist, writer and orator, would have turned [...]

Genius of the Ancient World - SocratesFew figures have been more important and influential in the history of civilization than the ancient [...]

The PresocraticsAnyone who's ever contemplated Raphael's celebrated painting The School of Athens knows th [...]

President Obama's Farewell AddressAs his presidency sadly comes to an end, President Obama delivered last night what is sure to become [...]

John Berger - Ways of SeeingArt critic John Berger's recent death has left a huge void in the world of art appreciation. Wh [...]

Right Living, Thinking, Etc
  • Two Truths News
  • Natural Living-Healthy Planet

Shine the warm light of awareness on your thoughts and feelings, says Thich Nhat Hanh. The post The [...]

When the Buddha taught us to abstain from taking life, he didn’t make an exception for animals we li [...]

Each Friday, we share three topical longreads in our Weekend Reader newsletter. This week, LionsRoar [...]

Buddhism teaches us that the buddhas can appear in different bodies. Finn Enke chronicles a lifelong [...]

A cup of tea or coffee is a nice break. Drinking it mindfully is a real break. Joseph Emet teaches u [...]

"No one who has ever touched liberation could possibly want anything other than liberation for [...]

A group of prominent Buddhist nuns has asked the Foundation for the Preservation of the Mahayana Tra [...]

57-year-old Sutham Nateetong plans to complete his 3,000 mile journey by the end of June. The post B [...]

A new report from Religion News Service details financial troubles facing the Shambhala Buddhist com [...]

Three teachers respond to the question: How would you counsel someone who is considering getting an [...]

(Natural News) Before the global warming era, which began sometime during the 1980s, there was a dif [...]

(Natural News) No one would argue that getting cancer is a stroke of bad luck — but is that really t [...]

(Natural News) If you’re concerned about diabetes, the first thing your doctor might suggest is gett [...]

(Natural News) If you go out in the woods today, you’re in for a big surprise. That line from a favo [...]

(Natural News) We live in a time where we have all manner of modern conveniences, but many of them a [...]

(Natural News) About three decades have passed since scientists made the devastating discovery that [...]

(Natural News) Many developing countries around the world rely heavily on traditional medicine; howe [...]

(Natural News) A study in the Journal of Essential Oil Research evaluated the chemical composition a [...]

(Natural News) Perhaps the best-known and healthiest yoga pose is the downward-facing dog pose. It i [...]

(Natural News) You woke up early with your morning workout already planned. The moment you get out o [...]

Science News
  • The Universe Today
  • Perimeter Institute
  • Science Daily
  • Sky and Telescope

A new study by an astrophysicist and a professor of ethics takes a look at the future of humanity in [...]

Welcome to the 612th Carnival of Space! The Carnival is a community of space science and astronomy w [...]

A planetary nebula is one of the most beautiful objects in the universe. Formed from the decaying re [...]

In the ongoing search for intelligent life, a new study recommends that we look for signs of an adva [...]

Sad fact of the Universe is that all stars will die, eventually. And when they do, what happens to t [...]

What is dark matter made of? It’s one of the most perplexing questions of modern astronomy. We know [...]

The Beresheet lander came oh-so-close to touching down on the surface of the Moon, but something wen [...]

The Moon’s going to have more human visitors in the year 2024. NASA has announced that their mission [...]

Hosts: Fraser Cain (universetoday.com / @fcain) Dr. Kimberly Cartier (KimberlyCartier.org / @AstroKi [...]

Anna Golubeva wins NSERC Brassard PrizeTuesday May 07, 2019Perimeter PhD student Anna Golubeva is ho [...]

New Simons Emmy Noether Fellows announcedFriday Mar 08, 2019Perimeter is set to welcome the next gro [...]

New Perimeter Institute Director among world’s most influential scientistsWednesday Feb 27, 2019Robe [...]

CONDENSED MATTER THEORIST CHONG WANG JOINS FACULTYFriday Feb 22, 2019For Perimeter’s newest faculty [...]

Perimeter researchers continue hot streak in Buchalter Cosmology Prize competitionWednesday Jan 09, [...]

New fellowships to fuel fundamental physics with radio telescopes in Canada Thursday Dec 20, 2018Per [...]

2018: Perimeter's scientific year in reviewMonday Dec 17, 2018As another year draws to a close, [...]

Perimeter ramps up efforts to support greater diversityFriday Nov 30, 2018Perimeter has taken anothe [...]

Exploring the physics all around usTuesday Nov 13, 2018From climate change to gravitational waves, t [...]

LUKE SANTI AWARD WINNER CULTIVATES CURIOSITY AND GRITWednesday Nov 07, 2018Aidan Richards, a first-y [...]

Formation of the moon brought water to EarthEarth has a large amount of water and a relatively large moon, which stabilizes Earth's axis. B [...]

Anxiety might be alleviated by regulating gut bacteriaPeople who experience anxiety symptoms might be helped by taking steps to regulate the microorganism [...]

Bonobo mothers help their sons to have more offspringNew research finds that bonobo mothers take action to ensure their sons will become fathers. This wa [...]

'Spider-like senses' could help autonomous machines see betterResearchers are building 'spidey senses' into the shells of autonomous cars and drones so [...]

Synthetic biologists hack bacterial sensorsSynthetic biologists have hacked bacterial sensing with a plug-and-play system that could be used to [...]

Counter-intuitive climate change solutionA seemingly counterintuitive approach -- converting one greenhouse gas into another -- holds promise [...]

How Earth's mantle is like a Jackson Pollock paintingNew research paints an intricate picture of Earth's mantle as a geochemically diverse mosaic, f [...]

Giant impact caused difference between Moon's hemispheresThe stark difference between the Moon's heavily-cratered farside and the lower-lying open basin [...]

Gas insulation could be protecting an ocean inside PlutoComputer simulations provide compelling evidence that an insulating layer of gas hydrates could keep [...]

Dietary cholesterol or egg consumption do not increase the risk of stroke, Finnish study findsA new study Finland shows that a moderately high intake of dietary cholesterol or consumption of up [...]

The post NGC 891 (also known as Caldwell 23 and Silver Sliver Galaxy) appeared first on Sky & Te [...]

The post Another Kind of “Blue” Moon appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post The Dumbbell Nebula (also known as Apple Core Nebula, Messier 27, M 27, or NGC 6853) appear [...]

New research shows that our quiet, middle-aged galaxy used to be quite the firecracker — a couple bi [...]

The Moon, nearly full, shines in dim Libra. Find Arcturus very high above the Moon. Less far to the [...]

In Sky & Telescope's July 2019 issue, we focus on the Moon: celebrating the 50th anniversar [...]

The post Rare Sunspot “Spotted” appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post Horsehead aka Barnard 33 & Flame NGC 2024 Nebulae in the constellation Orion appeared f [...]

The post M51 – Whirlpool Galaxy – LRGB and Ha appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post The Moon in M44 appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]