Northwestern University Library.jpg


Kant Confessed His Suspicions about the Limitations of His System, but Persisted Anyway

Immanuel Kant

It is a mark of courage or at least bold if not heroic confidence that Kant forged ahead with his attempt to describe the mechanisms and functions of human cognition, even though he suspected that some of the descriptive ideas he invented would probably never be scientifically verified.

In a section of the Critique of Pure Reason, titled “The Schematism of the Pure Concepts of the Understanding” (chapter 1 of book 2 of the “Transcendental Analytic”) he wrote:

This schematism of our understanding, in its application to appearances and their mere form, is an art concealed in the depths of the human soul, whose real modes of activity nature is hardly likely ever to allow us to discover, and to have open to our gaze.

Preceding this pessimistic observation, Kant had been explaining his hypothesized “schema” as rules for how to conjoin or link an a priori concept that is not dependent on sensual experience with an object of perception obtained through the senses. He uses several examples to illustrate. With the example of a triangle he asserts that associating the concept of triangle with an empirically apprehend image of a triangle is effected by means of set of innate rules or instructions that he calls a schema. A “schematism” according to Kant is an application of a set of rules whereby a pure, a priori concept of understanding such as space, time, triangle, or number is correlated with an empirically constituted object or idea.

But in the interjected “aside” to the reader quoted above, Kant expresses his suspicion that “nature is hardly likely ever to allow us to discover” the “real modes of activity” that constitute the functioning of those schema, or rules for linking the inner, mental world of pure concepts with sensibly perceived objects or empirically derived ideas.

Kant may have been trying with his schema — sets of rules for linking a priori concepts with sensually perceived objects — to (among other things) heal the body/mind split of Descartes. If Kant was right about “nature” being likely to never allow us to “gaze” upon schema, then neuroscientists who today address the hard problem of consciousness by mapping the areas of the brain that correlate with subjectively reported states of consciousness (qualia), observed behavior, or visible correlates of autonomic nerve activity, these neuroscientists may then, like Kant, worry that they too will likely never succeed in actually “gazing” on the mechanisms (schema, rules) that link inner consciousness experience with the exterior world of things.

More than 230 years following the publication of Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason, many philosophers and cognitive scientists working with or following the ideas of philosophers like Daniel Dennett, prefer not to invent and use terms or ideas like Kant’s “schema” — the hypothesized (invisible, postulated, unverifiable) rules for how we link or associate inner concepts with perceived objects. They avoid and argue against using scientifically unverifiable ideas or hypotheses. They, like Dennett, will for the sake of argument deign to take up for discussion ideas that are not susceptible to empirical proof (cf. the ether and phlogiston hypotheses), but then, after discussing and exposing their vacuousness and unusability, summarily drop them, and urge others to do the same.

Daniel Dennett

Knowing what terms or ideas to avoid using in attempting scientifically to solve the riddle and mystery of consciousness is important. Knowing what not to do or think is progress. But the hard problem of consciousness (what is like to be somethingqualiaJohn Searle’s Chinese roomMary the color-blind super scientist) is still unsolved. Notwithstanding his occasional use of non-verifiable ideas like “schema” and “schematism,” Kant’s attempts in the Critique to heal the mind-body split deduced by René Descarte in his Meditations, argue against the empirical skepticism expressed by David Hume in his Treatise and Enquiry, and correct or balance the radical empiricism of John Locke’s Essay surely contain many useable ideas that can be “operationalized” by neuroscientists, cognitive researchers, and philosophers of consciousness in their attempt to solve, understand, and explain the “hard problem” of consciousness.

Robert Paul Wolff

Robert Paul Wolff

A book published many years ago by Robert Paul Wolff, Kant’s Theory of Mental Activity: A Commentary on the Transcendental Analytic of the Critique of Pure Reason (Harvard University Press, 1963; Kindle [Society for Philosophy and Culture, 2013]) is the best commentary I have yet read on Kant’s Critique. Wolff has also recorded and published on YouTube a very helpful nine-part lecture series on the Critique.


August 2020
Politics, Culture, Philosophy
  • Rachel Maddow
  • Frank Schaeffer
  • Roberto Ruiz

Russian election interference finds ready conduit in GOP senatorsRachel Maddow notes an particularly specific warning from the director of the ODNI's National C

Trump campaign running two candidates for president in WisconsinRachel Maddow points out that one of the lawyers representing the Trump campaign in a court case in

Rachel Maddow 8/7/20Watch the full episode of Friday night's The Rachel Maddow Show.

Rachel Maddow 8/7/20Watch the full episode of Friday night's The Rachel Maddow Show.

Executives used NRA as 'personal piggy bank': New York AG lawsuitNew York Attorney General Letitia James describes the corruption within the NRA's leadership th

Lawsuit paints vivid picture of how NRA membership money is spentRachel Maddow reviews some of the ways NRA CEO Wayne LaPierre, his family, and other NRA executives

FBI asked to investigate reports of Trump UK golf club schemeRep. Ted Lieu talks with Rachel Maddow about why he and Rep. Kathleen Rice have asked the FBI to ope

Rachel Maddow 8/6/20Watch the full episode of Thursday night's The Rachel Maddow Show.

Rachel Maddow 8/6/20Watch the full episode of Thursday night's The Rachel Maddow Show.

Trump dinged by social media for 'harmful COVID misinformation'Rachel Maddow reports on a video of Donald Trump making false statements about children and the coro

Read at Down With Tyranny Yesterday, Carlos Lozada reviewed Jean Guerrero’s new book, Hatemonger: St

Trump got the emotions right. He won in 2016 because he understood that white evangelical and conser

Opinion by Ruth MarcusDeputy editorial page editor Read at Washington Post U.S. District Court Judge

When confronted with the reality of over 160,000 Americans dead from his failure to contain the pand

Schumer seeks documents on appointment of Trump ally by JACOB BOGAGE THE WASHINGTON POST WASHINGTON

Bortac, a quasi-militarised outfit some compare to the Navy Seals, has been deployed in Iraq and Afg

Please watch and share this video with everyone you know. We must get out in front of Donald Trump’s

As mail-in voting numbers are expected to surge, Trump’s new postmaster general is cranking back on

If you’re an officer of the law, dress like one. Leave the soldiering to soldiers. By The Editorial

Hi, my name is Frank Schaeffer. I’m a writer who grew up as the son of an evangelical leader in the

After having been unjustly convicted of the bogus charges brought against him in that most infamous

The Philosophy of Christopher NolanEver since I first watched Memento and its fascinating exploration of the philosophical question of

Voltaire - CandideThe philosophical problem of evil—the question of how the existence of unnecessary suffering is poss

Arrow - A Celebration of LoveLife is hard enough as it is. Existence, in many ways, is suffering. Obviously, some have it much wo

If 'Despacito' Were Written by an Evo-Devo BiologistIf you are a geek, you are likely to get excited over things others might find boring, laughable, la

James Baldwin Debates William F. BuckleyJames Baldwin, the great essayist, poet, civil rights activist, writer and orator, would have turned

Genius of the Ancient World - SocratesFew figures have been more important and influential in the history of civilization than the ancient

The PresocraticsAnyone who's ever contemplated Raphael's celebrated painting The School of Athens knows th

President Obama's Farewell AddressAs his presidency sadly comes to an end, President Obama delivered last night what is sure to become

John Berger - Ways of SeeingArt critic John Berger's recent death has left a huge void in the world of art appreciation. Wh

Right Living, Thinking, Etc
  • Two Truths News
  • Natural Living-Healthy Planet

At first glance, the Abhidharma, with all its lists and analysis, may not seem so inviting. But give

If love were enough to truly help others, there would only be one kind of bodhisattva. Melvin McLeod

The September 2020 issue of Lion's Roar magazine features Buddhist wisdom and meditations on th

With her empowered imagery, she’s connected countless women, and men, to the divine feminine. She ha

Stephen Murphy-Shigematsu shows us how we can truly connect with others with the Zulu practice of Sa

Equanimity protects us from emotional overreaction and allows us to rest in a bigger perspective. Ch

Ministering to the sick, the dying, and their loved ones is hard enough at the best of times. Four c

Lama Rod Owens on taking care of your own needs when you don’t see yourself represented in those aro

To be without a reference point is the ultimate loneliness. It is also called enlightenment. The pos

Just added to the Lion’s Roar store: six new, gorgeous prints from our “Buddhas and Bodhisattvas” co

(Natural News) You may recall that a couple of months ago, after President Trump announced “Operatio

(Natural News) On July 31, The Washington Post media critic Margaret Sullivan wrote a scathing criti

(Natural News) A new poll from Morning Consult and Politico claims that a majority of Americans supp

(Natural News) Get ready America to be microchipped with electronic transmitters that communicate wi

(Natural News) A bug-out bag (BOB) lets you carry all the items you’ll need to survive for 72 hours

(Natural News) Why most Jewish Americans continue to support a Democrat Party that tolerates some of

(Natural News) More than 100 law enforcement officers trying to keep the peace in Portland amid ongo

(Natural News) Foreign governments have been influencing and infiltrating American universities, usi

(Natural News) When it comes to black and brown children excelling at school, the biggest barrier to

(Natural News) The Antifa and Black Lives Matter rioters in Portland, Oregon have once again updated

Science News
  • The Universe Today
  • Perimeter Institute
  • Science Daily
  • Sky and Telescope

An international team of astronomers discovered some surprising when studying a debris ring around o

Protoplanetary disks – where young stars are forming their families of planets – usually form concen

We know that the carbon in your bones was formed long ago in the heart of a star. But how did that c

At first glance, it looks like something from an alien autopsy. A strange organ cut from a xenomorph

Is it possible that the aliens are not hiding, but sleeping and waiting for the Universe to get bett

It's August and that means the Perseid meteors are inbound, starting this weekend this shower i

Twinkling stars might make for spectacular viewing on a hot summer’s night, but they are an absolute

Astronomers have found another strange exoplanet in a distant solar system. This one’s an oddball be

Orbiters are giving us a chance to study the surface of Mars closely, and some of the features that

Since it launched in 2010, the Solar Dynamics Observatory has helped scientists understand how the S

CHIME receives Governor General’s Innovation AwardWednesday Jul 15, 2020The CHIME team is recognized

Perimeter participates in #Strike4BlackLivesFriday Jun 26, 2020Perimeter Institute participated in t

Perimeter among top winners at CCAE AwardsTuesday Jun 16, 2020The Canadian Council for the Advanceme

Four new Simons Emmy Noether Fellows announcedMonday Jun 15, 2020The next group of Simons Emmy Noeth

Anna Golubeva earns Borealis AI FellowshipMonday Jun 08, 2020Perimeter PhD student named one of 10 B

Kevin Costello admitted as Honorary Member of the Royal Irish AcademyWednesday May 27, 2020Perimeter

Flash of insight opens new paths for Luke Santi Award winnerThursday Mar 26, 2020Mackenzie Pereira,

PI-NRC partnership to fuel made-in-Canada breakthroughsTuesday Mar 03, 2020A new collaboration betwe

Introducing three new associate faculty at Perimeter InstituteFriday Feb 21, 2020Researchers in quan

Perimeter research recognized again by Buchalter Cosmology PrizeMonday Jan 06, 2020Perimeter Associa

A large number of the valley networks scarring Mars's surface were carved by water melting bene

New genetic and patient analyses suggest severe COVID is linked to overactive complement, one of the

Two NASA astronauts splashed down safely in the Gulf of Mexico Sunday for the first time in a commer

Ancient sediment found in a central Texas cave appears to solve the mystery of why the Earth cooled

Scientists have developed a new model that successfully predicted seven of the Sun's biggest fl

When we say someone has a quick mind, it may be in part thanks to our expanded cerebellum that disti

A new study shows other stars could have as many as seven Earth-like planets in the absence of a gas

NASA's Mars 2020 Perseverance rover mission is on its way to the Red Planet to search for signs

Based on ALMA observations and a theoretical follow-up study, scientists suggest that a neutron star

Geological evidence suggests the known dinosaur groups diverged early on, supporting the traditional

It's Perseid meteor week! The shower peaks on the night of August 11th, but you may see the occ

The Hayabusa 2 team has laid out a proposal for an extended mission to one of two asteroids after th

The annual Perseid meteor shower is upon us. The peak is expected to occur during the night of Augus

Astronomers thought giant stars were reponsible for flooding the early system with a radioative isot

A new model suggests that Martian valley networks might have been created by ancient subglacial rive

The Perseids are upon us — and as you're looking out for shooting stars, look for Jupiter and S

After decades of searching, astronomers have finally found the collapsed core of the nearest superno

The latest data release from a survey of 31 million galaxies reveals that our universe is even smoot

Mars rises in the east around 11 p.m. daylight saving time this week, in Pisces. Watch for it to com

NASA’s Perseverance rover heads to the Red Planet. The post NASA Launches Perseverance Rover for Mar