Pacific Grove - Monterey, CA.jpg

Critical theory

Gerald Graff and the Future of Critical Pedagogy

Gerald Graff

Gerald Graff

Gerald Graff In his early books, Literature Against Itself (1979) and Professing Literature: An Institutional History (1987), Graff took as his main subjects literary theory and the institutional history of departments of English and literature, respectively. Literature Against Itself continues to be of interest and value for its discussion and analysis of competing schools of literary theory; and the historical narrative of the history of the post-secondary teaching of English that informs Professing Literature continues to enlighten anyone interested in curriculum design and canon-making. But perhaps these two early books can also be appreciated for their having afforded Graff the opportunity to work out the foundational arguments and historical perspectives that enabled him in his later books — Beyond the Culture Wars: How Teaching the Conflicts Can Revitalize American Education (1992) and Clueless in Academe: How Schooling Obscures the Life of the Mind(2003) — to effectively argue and explain why students across the curriculum would benefit from a more critical style of pedagogy.

In Literature Against Itself Graff analyzes the premises, conclusions, and implications of various literary theories and contemporary schools of criticism in terms of their validity and effectiveness for pedagogy and criticism. And in Professing Literature Graff shows how the various teaching methods and choices of texts in departments of literature from the nineteenth though the early twentieth century suggest that new methods and new canons of study-worthy texts will continue to appear. In the more recent Beyond the Culture Wars: How Teaching the Conflicts Can Revitalize American Education (1992), Graff foregrounds the conclusions and pedagogical injunctions proffered in his earlier books. In the decade following the publication of Beyond the Culture Wars, Graff himself decided to put the pedogogical injunctions based on his conclusions into practice, coediting, with James Phelan, two “critical controversy” textbooks: Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Tempest. Both of these textbooks are in their second editions. In his most recent book, Clueless in Academe: How Schooling Obscures the Life of the Mind (2003), Graff continues to explore the pedagogical implications of what he discovered in researching and writing his earlier books on theory and the institutional history of literature departments.

Teaching the controversies or conflicts has ironically even been taken up by a group which eschews rational argument — a sine qua non of Graff’s critical pedagogy: religious fundamentalists. I would agree to a certain extent with anyone who thinks it unfortunate that some religious fundamentalists — in their efforts to get creationist mythology (intelligent design) taught in public school science courses — have co-opted Graff’s phrase “teaching the controversies.” But consider what violence religious fundamentalists of all faiths have resorted to when discussion stops. So, however ironic or unintended, part of Graff’s legacy is to have afforded educators the pedagogic means to obviate the conditions in which thoughts of intellectual, political, or outright physical violence might flourish. So, by all means, let the fundamentalists, in good faith (interesting word!) teach the controversies — but in their religious schools not in public classrooms. Let the conflicts continue to be taught and discussed by everyone — rational free-thinkers and fundamentalists alike.

Let the controversies and the conversations they engender continue.

Share
Calendar
August 2017
M T W T F S S
« Aug    
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  
Archives
Culture, Philosophy, Humor

James Baldwin Debates William F. BuckleyJames Baldwin, the great essayist, poet, civil rights activist, writer and orator, would have turned [...]

Genius of the Ancient World - SocratesFew figures have been more important and influential in the history of civilization than the ancient [...]

The PresocraticsAnyone who's ever contemplated Raphael's celebrated painting The School of Athens knows th [...]

President Obama's Farewell AddressAs his presidency sadly comes to an end, President Obama delivered last night what is sure to become [...]

John Berger - Ways of SeeingArt critic John Berger's recent death has left a huge void in the world of art appreciation. Wh [...]

Some Thoughts and Feelings on the Aftermath of the ElectionWhen I saw that anger, hate and bigotry were going to win two nights ago, I had to unplug for a whil [...]

The Philosophy of Marvel's DaredevilEveryone is familiar with the most obvious tropes of superhero comics: exciting action sequences, sk [...]

How the Republican Party went from Lincoln to Trump, and the Democratic Party went from White Supremacy to ObamaWhen accused of promoting racist beliefs of policies, Republicans usually argue that it was their pa [...]

Simon Blackburn - Plato's RepublicThe term Utopia wasn't invented until 1516, when Thomas More published his now classic renditio [...]

Introduction to Symbolic & Philosophical LogicAlthough almost every activity human beings engage in requires some degree of reasoning, we're [...]

Right Living, Thinking, Etc
  • Two Truths News
  • Natural Living-Healthy Planet

Complaining: we all do it. Dr. Elizabeth Williams breaks it all down from a Buddhist psychologist’s [...]

angel Kyodo williams says we must stand up to racism and expose its institutionalized forms to uphol [...]

Tibetan teacher Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse Rinpoche has issued a public response to the allegations m [...]

Mushim Patricia Ikeda traces her path as a parent through some of the humorous, poignant and penetra [...]

For our practice to have meaning in today's world, says Greg Snyder, it must include a thorough [...]

Buddhadharma editor Tynette Deveaux reflects on the last fifteen years of the magazine, and reveals [...]

Rory Lindsay reviews "Catholicism and Zen" by Richard Bryan McDaniel; "The Life of My [...]

In this special anniversary issue, we celebrate with a selection of the best teachings and articles [...]

Buddhist student Kaitlyn Hatch wanted a prayer specifically designed for the divided, trying time we [...]

Pema Khandro Rinpoche on a bodhisattva’s love. The post Open Your Heart Further appeared first on Li [...]

(Natural News) A new “cyber dark ages” has descended upon the internet as Apple, AirBNB, Facebook an [...]

(Natural News) A recent study, led by Professor Seena Fazel of the University of Oxford’s Forensic P [...]

(Natural News) One out of every three Americans will get cancer in their lifetime, and only half of [...]

(Natural News) According to the CDC, breast cancer – the most common cause of cancer in women – clai [...]

(Natural News) When it comes to healthy eating, many of us are willing to put up with some less-than [...]

(Natural News) Between North Korea, which has been ramping up its anti-American rhetoric and conduct [...]

(Natural News) A new documentary called What the Health was critically panned by health experts and [...]

(Natural News) There is another supervitamin that slips by even the most health-conscious of people, [...]

(Natural News) White House chief strategist and free market advocate Steve Bannon made news late las [...]

Science News
  • The Universe Today
  • Perimeter Institute
  • Science Daily
  • Sky and Telescope

KENNEDY SPACE CENTER, FL - The last of NASA’s next generation Tracking and Data Relay Satellites (TR [...]

As part of its Planetary Science Deep Space SmallSat Studies program, NASA has selected a CubeSat mi [...]

An international team of scientists relied on a new kind of gravitational lensing to conduct a detai [...]

It's hard to believe: we're now just one short weekend away from the big ticket astronomic [...]

I’ve often been asked the question, “Can the astronauts on the Space Station see the stars?” Astrona [...]

KENNEDY SPACE CENTER, FL – Following a two day orbital chase and ballet of carefully choreographed t [...]

A team of international astronomers have just observed the most distant massive galaxy to date, prov [...]

This week’s Carnival of Space is hosted by Brian Wang at his Next Big Future blog. Click here to rea [...]

A new study from the University of Washington indicates that tidally-locked planets may be quite com [...]

KENNEDY SPACE CENTER, FL – Todays (Aug. 14) stunning SpaceX Space Station cargo delivery blastoff to [...]

Physics with a side of summer friendshipsThursday Aug 03, 2017 High-schoolers from across the globe [...]

EinsteinPlus: Come for the fun. Stay for the physics.Monday Jul 17, 2017 How Perimeter Institute’s a [...]

Perimeter voted among top Canadian workplacesThursday Jun 22, 2017 The inaugural Employee Recommende [...]

PSI celebrates another adventure in research and discoveryFriday Jun 16, 2017 Eighth class of Perime [...]

A new generation of NoethersTuesday May 30, 2017 Four talented physicists have been recruited as the [...]

Inside the Perimeter Magazine: Spring/Summer 2017Thursday May 25, 2017 For more than 150 years, Cana [...]

Raymond Laflamme wins CAP-CRM PrizeMonday Apr 24, 2017 IQC Executive Director's work in quantum [...]

Myers Named Among World's Most Influential Scientists for Third Straight YearWednesday Feb 22, [...]

Perimeter achieves double-hat-trick at Buchalter Cosmology PrizeTuesday Jan 17, 2017 For the third t [...]

Inside the Perimeter Magazine: Fall-Winter 2016/17Tuesday Dec 13, 2016 Science is a participatory en [...]

New gene catalog of ocean microbiome reveals surprisesOceanographers report completing the largest single-site microbiome gene catalog constructed to date [...]

Gene that makes large, plump tomatoes identifiedFarmers can grow big, juicy tomatoes thanks to a mutation in the cell size regulator gene that occur [...]

New technique overcomes genetic cause of infertilityScientists have created healthy offspring from genetically infertile male mice, offering a potential [...]

Non-toxic, lubricant-infused coatings deter mussels and prevent their attachment by disrupting their mechanosensory and adhesive systemsMussels are one of the worst perpetrators of biofouling, or the unwanted accumulation of organisms o [...]

New Pathology Atlas maps genes in cancer to accelerate progress in personalized medicineA new Pathology Atlas is launched today with an analysis of all human genes in all major cancers sho [...]

Communicating in a foreign language takes emotion out of decision-makingIf you could save the lives of five people by pushing another bystander in front of a train to his d [...]

Artificial womb raises hope for premature babiesResearchers hope an artificial womb used to incubate healthy baby lambs can be used in future techno [...]

Bacteria stab amoebae with micro-daggersResearchers have discovered a type of bacteria that uses tiny daggers to prevent itself from being e [...]

Female mouse embryos actively remove male reproductive systemsA protein called COUP-TFII determines whether a mouse embryo develops a male reproductive tract, acc [...]

Researchers have devised a method to selectively erase particular fear memories by weakening the con [...]

A peculiar white dwarf could be what’s left after a failed supernova explosion. The post The White D [...]

Enrich the eclipse experience — especially the long, partial phases — with solar eclipse activities [...]

If you're itching to know the weather on eclipse day, here's how you can explore weather m [...]

Updated 8/16 to include Predictive Science, Inc.'s predictions. The total solar eclipse is less [...]

Join host Michelle Thaller as she learns about the IceBridge mission and the scientific discoveries [...]

Total eclipses have the power to touch us deeply and reverberate through our life in unexpected ways [...]

The post kappa-Cygnid appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

Barely visible water-ice clouds coast across Mars’s skies in new videos from the Curiosity rover. Th [...]

A few weeks ago we took to Twitter and Facebook to find out what questions you wanted answered about [...]

Astronomers have used an innovative technique to discover four super-Earth-size planet candidates or [...]