University Hall - Northwestern University.jpg

Kant Confessed His Suspicions about the Limitations of His System, but Persisted Anyway

Immanuel Kant

It is a mark of courage or at least bold if not heroic confidence that Kant forged ahead with his attempt to describe the mechanisms and functions of human cognition, even though he suspected that some of the descriptive ideas he invented would probably never be scientifically verified.

In a section of the Critique of Pure Reason, titled “The Schematism of the Pure Concepts of the Understanding” (chapter 1 of book 2 of the “Transcendental Analytic”) he wrote:

This schematism of our understanding, in its application to appearances and their mere form, is an art concealed in the depths of the human soul, whose real modes of activity nature is hardly likely ever to allow us to discover, and to have open to our gaze.

Preceding this pessimistic observation, Kant had been explaining his hypothesized “schema” as rules for how to conjoin or link an a priori concept that is not dependent on sensual experience with an object of perception obtained through the senses. He uses several examples to illustrate. With the example of a triangle he asserts that associating the concept of triangle with an empirically apprehend image of a triangle is effected by means of set of innate rules or instructions that he calls a schema. A “schematism” according to Kant is an application of a set of rules whereby a pure, a priori concept of understanding such as space, time, triangle, or number is correlated with an empirically constituted object or idea.

But in the interjected “aside” to the reader quoted above, Kant expresses his suspicion that “nature is hardly likely ever to allow us to discover” the “real modes of activity” that constitute the functioning of those schema, or rules for linking the inner, mental world of pure concepts with sensibly perceived objects or empirically derived ideas.

Kant may have been trying with his schema — sets of rules for linking a priori concepts with sensually perceived objects — to (among other things) heal the body/mind split of Descartes. If Kant was right about “nature” being likely to never allow us to “gaze” upon schema, then neuroscientists who today address the hard problem of consciousness by mapping the areas of the brain that correlate with subjectively reported states of consciousness (qualia), observed behavior, or visible correlates of autonomic nerve activity, these neuroscientists may then, like Kant, worry that they too will likely never succeed in actually “gazing” on the mechanisms (schema, rules) that link inner consciousness experience with the exterior world of things.

More than 230 years following the publication of Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason, many philosophers and cognitive scientists working with or following the ideas of philosophers like Daniel Dennett, prefer not to invent and use terms or ideas like Kant’s “schema” — the hypothesized (invisible, postulated, unverifiable) rules for how we link or associate inner concepts with perceived objects. They avoid and argue against using scientifically unverifiable ideas or hypotheses. They, like Dennett, will for the sake of argument deign to take up for discussion ideas that are not susceptible to empirical proof (cf. the ether and phlogiston hypotheses), but then, after discussing and exposing their vacuousness and unusability, summarily drop them, and urge others to do the same.

Daniel Dennett

Knowing what terms or ideas to avoid using in attempting scientifically to solve the riddle and mystery of consciousness is important. Knowing what not to do or think is progress. But the hard problem of consciousness (what is like to be somethingqualiaJohn Searle’s Chinese roomMary the color-blind super scientist) is still unsolved. Notwithstanding his occasional use of non-verifiable ideas like “schema” and “schematism,” Kant’s attempts in the Critique to heal the mind-body split deduced by René Descarte in his Meditations, argue against the empirical skepticism expressed by David Hume in his Treatise and Enquiry, and correct or balance the radical empiricism of John Locke’s Essay surely contain many useable ideas that can be “operationalized” by neuroscientists, cognitive researchers, and philosophers of consciousness in their attempt to solve, understand, and explain the “hard problem” of consciousness.

Robert Paul Wolff

Robert Paul Wolff

A book published many years ago by Robert Paul Wolff, Kant’s Theory of Mental Activity: A Commentary on the Transcendental Analytic of the Critique of Pure Reason (Harvard University Press, 1963; Kindle [Society for Philosophy and Culture, 2013]) is the best commentary I have yet read on Kant’s Critique. Wolff has also recorded and published on YouTube a very helpful nine-part lecture series on the Critique.

 

Share

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Calendar
July 2018
M T W T F S S
« Oct    
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  
Archives
Politics, Culture, Philosophy
  • Rachel Maddow
  • Frank Schaeffer
  • Roberto Ruiz

Tensions between Trump and US intelligence agencies reach a new levelDespite his Monday comments, Trump now claims to have "full faith in our intelligence agencies. [...]

Wednesday's Campaign Round-Up, 7.18.18Today's installment of campaign-related news items from across the country. [...]

Ryan shows no real interest in trying to constrain TrumpA recent poll found 71% of Americans want Congress to serve as a check on Trump. With this in mind, [...]

Are White House transcripts getting politically motivated touch-ups?There was something important missing from the White House transcript of the Trump-Putin press confe [...]

Trump's new Supreme Court nominee fails to garner broad public supportBy some measures, Judge Brett Kavanaugh enjoys less public support than any Supreme Court nominee in [...]

Trump questions value of the NATO alliance's core principleEvery modern president has recognized and appreciated the inherent value of NATO as an enduring inst [...]

Trump tries and fails to clean up his Putin summit messFollowing his disastrous press conference on Monday, Donald Trump tried to clean up his mess by sayi [...]

Widespread protests on tap after Trump show of servility to PutinRachel Maddow reports on planning for a "Confront Corruption: Demand Democracy" protest ta [...]

Mueller looks to give immunity to five witnesses in Manafort caseJoyce Vance, former U.S. attorney, explains to Rachel Maddow what it means that Robert Mueller wants [...]

Murphy: The good news is we're only four months from an electionSenator Chris Murphy talks with Rachel Maddow about the obstacle congressional Republicans pose to C [...]

From McCain (R): “Today’s press conference in Helsinki was one of the most disgraceful performances [...]

As the world rejoices, remember how Donald Trump and Stephen Miller really feel about brown children [...]

 Vote Common Good Bus Tour, Sept. 6 – Nov. 6. Learn More. How do we make our way back into love, be [...]

I would ask Trump’s evangelical supporters, Was it ever about the children, or was it only about whi [...]

This new leg of my Road Trip took me to the beautiful mountain hamlet of Ouray, Colorado to speak at [...]

If Republicans let Trump roll them by using innocent children as hostages, he will learn the lesson [...]

ICYMI, I appeared this morning on AM Joy on MSNBC with Bishop William Barber and Bishop Michael Curr [...]

If you’ve been following this new leg of my Road Trip, you know I recently travelled to the beautifu [...]

As you may know, I recently spoke at San Juans Summit, a gathering put together by Common Good Chris [...]

I recently spoke at San Juans Summit, a gathering of progressive Christians who want to take back th [...]

After having been unjustly convicted of the bogus charges brought against him in that most infamous [...]

The Philosophy of Christopher NolanEver since I first watched Memento and its fascinating exploration of the philosophical question of [...]

Voltaire - CandideThe philosophical problem of evil—the question of how the existence of unnecessary suffering is poss [...]

Arrow - A Celebration of LoveLife is hard enough as it is. Existence, in many ways, is suffering. Obviously, some have it much wo [...]

If 'Despacito' Were Written by an Evo-Devo BiologistIf you are a geek, you are likely to get excited over things others might find boring, laughable, la [...]

James Baldwin Debates William F. BuckleyJames Baldwin, the great essayist, poet, civil rights activist, writer and orator, would have turned [...]

Genius of the Ancient World - SocratesFew figures have been more important and influential in the history of civilization than the ancient [...]

The PresocraticsAnyone who's ever contemplated Raphael's celebrated painting The School of Athens knows th [...]

President Obama's Farewell AddressAs his presidency sadly comes to an end, President Obama delivered last night what is sure to become [...]

John Berger - Ways of SeeingArt critic John Berger's recent death has left a huge void in the world of art appreciation. Wh [...]

Right Living, Thinking, Etc
  • Two Truths News
  • Natural Living-Healthy Planet

After learning to meditate while trapped in a flooded cave for 10 days, the Wild Boars soccer team m [...]

How can we follow the news in ways that nurture – and don’t diminish – wellbeing? Media scholar Holl [...]

Sister True Dedication, a Buddhist teacher and former BBC journalist, offers tips for keeping your h [...]

Just as you consume food, you consume media. And like food, some media is wholesome and some is unhe [...]

We've got a question for you. How does Buddhism inform the way you date? If you’ve got an answe [...]

How have Buddhists become implicated in one of the worst humanitarian crises in the world? Randy Ros [...]

Charlene Leung discusses the importance of using Buddhist practice to become aware of our biases and [...]

Buddhist teacher Jan Willis shares her advice for making the most of your bravery, your voice, and y [...]

Each Friday, we share three topical longreads in our Weekend Reader newsletter. This week, LionsRoar [...]

Debating the supernatural in Buddhism with Judy Lief, Ari Goldfield, and Glenn Wallis. The post Foru [...]

(Natural News) In recent weeks a couple of conservative media outlets have begun tallying the number [...]

(Natural News) A popular New York-based co-working company with more than 400 locations worldwide ha [...]

(Natural News) Are genetically modified crops actually equivalent to real food? New research has sho [...]

(Natural News) Joel Davis, chairman of the International Campaign to Stop Rape and Gender Violence i [...]

(Natural News) One in every three Americans will “contract” some form of cancer in their lifetime, a [...]

(Natural News) It appears as though the answer to the question, “Is the Deep State real?” has been a [...]

(Natural News) Genetically modified organisms, or GMOs, have been a hot button issue for many years [...]

(Natural News) Playing video games is not bad for you, as long as it is in moderation. In fact, one [...]

(Natural News) People who have suffered a stroke need to relearn the skills that they may have lost, [...]

(Natural News) Where the federal government’s rights end and states’ rights begin has become a gray [...]

Science News
  • The Universe Today
  • Perimeter Institute
  • Science Daily
  • Sky and Telescope

This week’s Carnival of Space is hosted by Brian Wang at his Next Big Future blog. Click here to rea [...]

When the James Webb Space Telescope is deployed, it will study and characterize the atmospheres of g [...]

Have you been checking out Mars this season? Mars reaches opposition on July 27th at 5:00 Universal [...]

Using data from the Juno spacecraft, a team of scientists found a heat source on Io that could be a [...]

A new study used data from both Hubble and Gaia in order to obtain the most precise measurements of [...]

A new study by a team from NASA JPL has shown how Europa's interior ocean rises to the surface [...]

According to a recent study by an international team of researchers, Jupiter's moons of Io and [...]

In recognition of their efforts to communicate the importance of the Cassini mission, NASA's JP [...]

A new research study conducted by an international team of researchers indicates that life can survi [...]

The Kepler mission has been put into hibernation prior to downloading data from its 18th campaign an [...]

Teachers become pupils at immersive physics campMonday Jul 16, 2018Fourty-four teachers from around [...]

Quantum researcher honoured with KnighthoodMonday Jul 09, 2018Perimeter Associate Faculty member Mic [...]

Neil Turok appointed to Order of CanadaThursday Jun 28, 2018Perimeter Director “surprised and very h [...]

From learners to creators: Perimeter’s ninth PSI class graduates Wednesday Jun 20, 2018Class of 30 s [...]

ELIZABETH GOULD EARNS W.B. PEARSON MEDALTuesday Jun 19, 2018Perimeter PhD graduate earns top honours [...]

ELEVEN PERIMETER RESEARCHERS AWARDED NSERC DISCOVERY GRANTSTuesday Jun 19, 2018A record number of Pe [...]

Perimeter Outreach builds Californian connectionsTuesday Jun 12, 2018Perimeter’s Educational Outreac [...]

Perimeter scoops four awards at CCAE Prix d’ExcellenceThursday Jun 07, 2018Perimeter lauded at natio [...]

NEW CENTRE FOR ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS LAUNCHES IN CANADAThursday May 10, 2018Perimeter Institute is a [...]

PERIMETER RESEARCHER ELECTED TO ROYAL SOCIETYWednesday May 09, 2018Mathematical physicist Kevin Cost [...]

Ozone pollution in US national parks close to that of largest US citiesThe research matched pollution data to monthly park visitation statistics at 33 heavily visited nati [...]

Great Barrier Reef not bouncing back as before, but there is hopeThe Great Barrier Reef is losing its ability to recover from disturbances, but effective local manag [...]

Glowing bacteria on deep-sea fish shed light on evolution, 'third type' of symbiosisFor the first time, scientists have sequenced and analyzed the genomes of bacteria that live in angl [...]

Billion-year-old lake deposit yields clues to Earth's ancient biosphereA sample of ancient oxygen, teased out of a 1.4-billion-year-old evaporative lake deposit in Ontario [...]

Light-controlled polymers can switch between sturdy and softResearchers have designed a polymer material that can change its structure in response to light, con [...]

Atlantic circulation is not collapsing -- but as it shifts gears, warming will reaccelerateData suggest that the recent, rapid slowdown of the Atlantic Ocean circulation is not a sign of immi [...]

Scientists have discovered never-before-detected, fine-grained structures in the Sun's outer at [...]

Neurons can carry more than one signal at a timeNew research shows that neurons in the brain can carry two signals at once, using a strategy similar [...]

Global study of world's beaches shows threat to protected areasA first-of-its-kind survey of the world's sandy shorelines with satellite data found that they [...]

Autism risk determined by health of mom's gutThe mother's microbiome, the collection of microscopic organisms that live inside us, determine [...]

The post Lunar/Venus Conjunction appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post The Yerkes refractor observing M17 appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post The Yerkes refractor observing M57 appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post The Yerkes refractor observing M13 appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post Throught the Dome- The 40 inch Yerkes refractor appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

Over the past 18 months, astronomers have painstakingly tracked a dozen tiny moons that they found c [...]

Comet PanSTARRS (C/2017 S3) has erupted again! Now bright enough to see in binoculars, it might beco [...]

The post Crescent Moon and Venus – Kilauea eruption appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post Comet 64P/Swift-Gehrels Gif appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post Comet 64P/Swift-Gehrels appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]