New York Public Library-2008-7.jpg

Science

Kant Confessed His Suspicions about the Limitations of His System, but Persisted Anyway

Immanuel Kant

It is a mark of courage or at least bold if not heroic confidence that Kant forged ahead with his attempt to describe the mechanisms and functions of human cognition, even though he suspected that some of the descriptive ideas he invented would probably never be scientifically verified.

In a section of the Critique of Pure Reason, titled “The Schematism of the Pure Concepts of the Understanding” (chapter 1 of book 2 of the “Transcendental Analytic”) he wrote:

This schematism of our understanding, in its application to appearances and their mere form, is an art concealed in the depths of the human soul, whose real modes of activity nature is hardly likely ever to allow us to discover, and to have open to our gaze.

Preceding this pessimistic observation, Kant had been explaining his hypothesized “schema” as rules for how to conjoin or link an a priori concept that is not dependent on sensual experience with an object of perception obtained through the senses. He uses several examples to illustrate. With the example of a triangle he asserts that associating the concept of triangle with an empirically apprehend image of a triangle is effected by means of set of innate rules or instructions that he calls a schema. A “schematism” according to Kant is an application of a set of rules whereby a pure, a priori concept of understanding such as space, time, triangle, or number is correlated with an empirically constituted object or idea.

But in the interjected “aside” to the reader quoted above, Kant expresses his suspicion that “nature is hardly likely ever to allow us to discover” the “real modes of activity” that constitute the functioning of those schema, or rules for linking the inner, mental world of pure concepts with sensibly perceived objects or empirically derived ideas.

Kant may have been trying with his schema — sets of rules for linking a priori concepts with sensually perceived objects — to (among other things) heal the body/mind split of Descartes. If Kant was right about “nature” being likely to never allow us to “gaze” upon schema, then neuroscientists who today address the hard problem of consciousness by mapping the areas of the brain that correlate with subjectively reported states of consciousness (qualia), observed behavior, or visible correlates of autonomic nerve activity, these neuroscientists may then, like Kant, worry that they too will likely never succeed in actually “gazing” on the mechanisms (schema, rules) that link inner consciousness experience with the exterior world of things.

More than 230 years following the publication of Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason, many philosophers and cognitive scientists working with or following the ideas of philosophers like Daniel Dennett, prefer not to invent and use terms or ideas like Kant’s “schema” — the hypothesized (invisible, postulated, unverifiable) rules for how we link or associate inner concepts with perceived objects. They avoid and argue against using scientifically unverifiable ideas or hypotheses. They, like Dennett, will for the sake of argument deign to take up for discussion ideas that are not susceptible to empirical proof (cf. the ether and phlogiston hypotheses), but then, after discussing and exposing their vacuousness and unusability, summarily drop them, and urge others to do the same.

Daniel Dennett

Knowing what terms or ideas to avoid using in attempting scientifically to solve the riddle and mystery of consciousness is important. Knowing what not to do or think is progress. But the hard problem of consciousness (what is like to be somethingqualiaJohn Searle’s Chinese roomMary the color-blind super scientist) is still unsolved. Notwithstanding his occasional use of non-verifiable ideas like “schema” and “schematism,” Kant’s attempts in the Critique to heal the mind-body split deduced by René Descarte in his Meditations, argue against the empirical skepticism expressed by David Hume in his Treatise and Enquiry, and correct or balance the radical empiricism of John Locke’s Essay surely contain many useable ideas that can be “operationalized” by neuroscientists, cognitive researchers, and philosophers of consciousness in their attempt to solve, understand, and explain the “hard problem” of consciousness.

Robert Paul Wolff

Robert Paul Wolff

A book published many years ago by Robert Paul Wolff, Kant’s Theory of Mental Activity: A Commentary on the Transcendental Analytic of the Critique of Pure Reason (Harvard University Press, 1963; Kindle [Society for Philosophy and Culture, 2013]) is the best commentary I have yet read on Kant’s Critique. Wolff has also recorded and published on YouTube a very helpful nine-part lecture series on the Critique.

 

Share

George Cantor, Ludwig Boltzmann, Kurt Gödel, and Alan Turning: “The Vertigo of the Modern”

A roller coaster ride for your mind — have a look at this documentary, “Dangerous Knowledge,” on the work of Georg Cantor, Kurt Gödel, and Alan Turing. YouTube changes its offerings for all sorts of reasons, so you might need search a bit if this video link goes bad. At one point, the narrator uses a most memorable phrase to characterize what it is to be “modern”— I can only paraphrase:

The vertigo of the modern: the whirlpool of thinking about thinking about thinking about thinking . . .

Share
Calendar
October 2020
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  
Archives
Politics, Culture, Philosophy
  • Error
  • Frank Schaeffer
  • Roberto Ruiz

RSS Error: A feed could not be found at `http://www.msnbc.com/feeds/rss/hub/234956`; the status code is `404` and content-type is `text/html; charset=utf-8`

So true. It is also sometimes very difficult to get the truth from the research engines. Companies t

"In everything, therefore, treat people the same way you want them to treat you, for this is th

Amy Coney Barrett is absolutely terrifying. Educated, professional women I come in contact with don’

Frank, I've followed you for a while now and have your "Lucy" book, which I love and

Very informative article. Thank you. My extended family is quite large. Most of them are prosperous,

I don’t know what liberals would do without your guidance Mr. Schaeffer. You give us raw power, thro

It's the evangelical religion that happens to borrow selectively from the Christian religion bu

Dear Frank, Trump's enablers are assortment of less than decent characters as you well know. Zu

I am a Vietnam veteran and that was mentioned to a man with whom I was doing business. He greatly of

I knew men who were professional gamblers and they were all good at their game, but they were also c

After having been unjustly convicted of the bogus charges brought against him in that most infamous

The Philosophy of Christopher NolanEver since I first watched Memento and its fascinating exploration of the philosophical question of

Voltaire - CandideThe philosophical problem of evil—the question of how the existence of unnecessary suffering is poss

Arrow - A Celebration of LoveLife is hard enough as it is. Existence, in many ways, is suffering. Obviously, some have it much wo

If 'Despacito' Were Written by an Evo-Devo BiologistIf you are a geek, you are likely to get excited over things others might find boring, laughable, la

James Baldwin Debates William F. BuckleyJames Baldwin, the great essayist, poet, civil rights activist, writer and orator, would have turned

Genius of the Ancient World - SocratesFew figures have been more important and influential in the history of civilization than the ancient

The PresocraticsAnyone who's ever contemplated Raphael's celebrated painting The School of Athens knows th

President Obama's Farewell AddressAs his presidency sadly comes to an end, President Obama delivered last night what is sure to become

John Berger - Ways of SeeingArt critic John Berger's recent death has left a huge void in the world of art appreciation. Wh

Right Living, Thinking, Etc
  • Two Truths News
  • Natural Living-Healthy Planet

From "The Pentacle" to Corpse Pose, yoga teacher Cyndi Lee invites you to open up and watc

In order to shed light on the realities of climate change, says Ajahn Sucitto, first we should get m

We’ve been sold on the idea that self-care means chocolates and bubble baths (not that there’s anyth

How do bodhisattvas respond to the greatest crisis of our time? Appropriately, says Buddhist teacher

Richard Gere, Karenna Gore, Robert Thurman, Sharon Salzberg, and Deepak Chopra headline this month

Each Friday, we share three topical longreads in our Weekend Reader newsletter. This week, LionsRoar

Each Friday, we share three topical longreads in our Weekend Reader newsletter. This week, Buddhist

In the midst of the Covid-19 pandemic, Holly Stocking found herself with an inescapable craving for

Their sangha gathered virtually, but it was still real. Rachel Paige King on the loss of an online d

What reveals itself when you do nothing at all? Vanessa Zuisei Goddard on the practice of “just sitt

(Natural News) Hackers linked to the Communist regime in China are once again targeting American mil

(Natural News) Ask yourself right now why the flu shot is almost always free, when all other prevent

(Natural News) In the wake of bombshell reports last week beginning with the New York Post that were

(Natural News) During the final year of Barack Obama’s occupation of the White House, then-Vice Pres

(Natural News) There’s no doubt that the Marxist attorney general in New York, Letitia Jones, hates

(Natural News) Experts in Japan are blaming the ongoing Wuhan coronavirus (COVID-19) for an increase

(Natural News) British pharmaceutical company AstraZeneca has commenced late-stage trials for its CO

(Natural News) A new study reveals that the Wuhan coronavirus can block pain and mask any symptoms i

(Natural News) Health Ranger Mike Adams recently interviewed New York Times best-selling author and

(Natural News) President Trump has suggested Rep. Adam Schiff (D-CA) should face “arrest for treason

Science News
  • The Universe Today
  • Perimeter Institute
  • Science Daily
  • Sky and Telescope

A team of researchers has discovered a complex network of filamentary structures in the Milky Way. T

To measure small differences in time, you need a really tiny clock, and researchers in Germany have

The Starship is coming together, literally and figuratively! With its three Raptor engines test fire

“This is where we live. On a Blue Dot.” said Carl Sagan when the now famous Pale Blue Dot photo was

All her life, Laci Shea Brock has needed to be creative and inventive. So, perhaps it’s not complete

A new analysis indicates that 3% of Starlink satellites have failed since they were launched to orbi

As we explore the solar system, we'll need an interplanetary communication network that can kee

Northern Canada has been keeping a secret from the rest of the world. It’s home to “Resurrection,” a

In 2005 astronomers found a dense grouping of stars in the Virgo constellation. It looked like a sta

In September, a team of scientists reported finding phosphine in the upper atmosphere of Venus. Phos

Perimeter Institute launches Clay Riddell Centre for Quantum MatterThursday Oct 15, 2020A new resear

Perimeter congratulates 2020 winners of the Nobel Prize in PhysicsTuesday Oct 06, 2020This year’s wi

CHIME receives Governor General’s Innovation AwardWednesday Jul 15, 2020The CHIME team is recognized

Perimeter participates in #Strike4BlackLivesFriday Jun 26, 2020Perimeter Institute participated in t

Perimeter among top winners at CCAE AwardsTuesday Jun 16, 2020The Canadian Council for the Advanceme

Four new Simons Emmy Noether Fellows announcedMonday Jun 15, 2020The next group of Simons Emmy Noeth

Anna Golubeva earns Borealis AI FellowshipMonday Jun 08, 2020Perimeter PhD student named one of 10 B

Kevin Costello admitted as Honorary Member of the Royal Irish AcademyWednesday May 27, 2020Perimeter

Flash of insight opens new paths for Luke Santi Award winnerThursday Mar 26, 2020Mackenzie Pereira,

PI-NRC partnership to fuel made-in-Canada breakthroughsTuesday Mar 03, 2020A new collaboration betwe

NASA's Stratospheric Observatory for Infrared Astronomy (SOFIA) has confirmed, for the first ti

Two days after touching down on asteroid Bennu, NASA's OSIRIS-REx mission team received on Thur

Humans are born with a part of the brain that is prewired to be receptive to seeing words and letter

New radio images from ALMA show for the first time the direct effect of volcanic activity on the atm

Three decades after astronomer Carl Sagan suggested that Voyager 1 snap Earth's picture from bi

The first analysis of a sedimentary drill core representing 1 million years of environmental history

NASA's Origins, Spectral Interpretation, Resource Identification, Security, Regolith Explorer (

Researchers have linked a brain region to what they call neural polarization, offering a glimpse int

Thin tissue grafts and flexible electronics have a host of applications for wound healing, regenerat

A pioneering technique which captures precisely how mountains bend to the will of raindrops has help

Astronomers have tallied how star-making material evolved over cosmic time — and they've predic

The Ghost of Summer Suns: Halloween is approaching, and this means that Arcturus, the star sparkling

See images and video from NASA’s Osiris-REX spacecraft as it samples the Nightingale site. The post

The Moon's magnetic field, now long gone, might once have shielded Earth from the young Sun

Comets have been scarce since NEOWISE departed the scene. Not anymore. Suddenly, there are four fres

NASA's Osiris-REX mission has successfully touched down on the asteroid Bennu to collect a samp

New research has shown that the recently-discovered closest black hole to Earth might not be a black

A silver lining to the long year we've had is a renewed interest in the night sky. The post Pan

Mars is edging away a bit now from its close approach to Earth, but on the other hand, it rises high

What "comes off the camera" is remarkably different in astrophotography than most photogra