Walden Pond - Concord, MA.jpg

Philosophy

Poets and Philosophers: Beyond Rhyme and Meter

Poets thrive on paradoxes, creating them, giving them expression; philosophers also thrive on paradox, but by explaining them away. Poets present things as they are; philosophers explain how things come to be.

John Keats

O for a Life of Sensations rather than of Thoughts!

Letter to Benjamin Bailey
22 November 1817

I mean Negative Capability, that is when man is capable of being in uncertainties, Mysteries, doubts without any irritable
reaching after fact & reason.

Letter to his brothers
21 December 1817

John Keats

Share

David J. Linden – The Accidental Mind: Point of Inquiry Interview

David Linden

David Linden

An new interview with neuroscientist David J. Linden provides some physiological context and grounding for reconsidering and thinking anew about what it means to be human.

From the Point of Inquiry introduction:

In this broad discussion with D.J. Grothe, David Linden challenges widespread beliefs about the brain, such as that people only use ten percent of it and that it is amazingly designed, arguing instead that the brain is “accidental.” . . . He discusses the neuron, and how it is a “lousy processor of information,” describing how evolution has nonetheless used it to build “clever us.” He talks about how our brains have constrained us, and may have physically led to the necessity of marriage, family and long childhoods. . . . And he argues that the brain has evolved to make everyone a “believer,” describing the similarities between belief in science and in religion, that both are similar “branches of the same cognitive stream.”

Click here for the complete Point of Inquiry introduction and links to the interview and the iTunes subscription page for P.O.I.

Share

Ken Wilber – The Asimov of Consciousness

The life and career of Ken Wilber is nothing if not interesting. A google search will reveal that episodes and chapters of recent years involve Wilber losing former fans, readers, followers, and promoters. Why? Ken Wilber is a scholar, critic, teacher, observer, and prolific writer who has written extensively and critically about science, psychology, religion, and philosophy–eastern as well as western. But he is not himself a peer of those whose writings and work he reports and critiques. This leaves profoundly disappointed many of those who take him to be or want him to be taken seriously by evolutionary biologists, academic philosophers, and practicing psychologists and neurobiologists. Wilber is an incredibly well-informed critical analyst and popularizer of the subjects he writes about, but he is not a practicing expert in any of them. Not that there is anything wrong with that.

Would it be so bad to begin thinking of Wilber as a critical writer whose essential role is to popularize promising lines of thought and research as they appear on the scene. He would make an interesting talking head on MSNBC or CNN. There is a place and a need for someone who can do for philosophy, evolutionary biology, brain research, and consciousness studies what Isaac Asimov did for the subjects he took up. Why not think of Ken Wilber as the Isaac Asimov of consciousness?

During the past 5 years or so, since the founding of his Integral Institute, Wilber left behind his erstwhile reclusive, private lifestyle to take up a very public, visible role in the activities of the Institute and its related enterprises. How it will all turn out remains an open question. Currently there are serious controversies dogging the Institute and Wilber. One of the biggest problems confronting Wilber is his unwillingness to engage his critics (many of them would-be sympathetic colleagues and students) in good faith argument and discussion.

A growing number of those who have been reading Ken Wilber since the mid-1970s have begun to compare his writings with the writings of figures in various other disciplines and subjects–evolution, Buddhism and Eastern philosophy, western philosophy, politics, literature, the arts in general. A growing number of these readers are coming to see that Wilber’s ideas are not all that original. OK. No blame there. Original ideas are hard to come by. But, as noted above, Wilber should not be taken as an exponent of original, cutting edge research and thought. Instead, Wilber writes critically about cutting edge research in science, philosophy, and psychology. Other venues and media Wilber uses to get his material to the public include his Integral Institute and regularly recorded and published interviews available on the internet and the What is Enlightenment magazine quarterly.

Wilber’s originality lies in his having mapped truly vast amounts of content from various philosophical, religious, psychological, and scientific systems of thought. But his claims and assertions for the applicability of his ideas (those of his AQAL model in particular) to not just psychology and philosophy but to politics, religion, education, law, art, business, acting, theatre, film, and ecology belie a premature, grandiose sense of their validity and importance.

In the mid 00s a number of readers and students of Wilber’s writings began to criticize his tone and style, characterizing it as arrogant, pompous, patronizing, and elitist. Some also commented on how annoyingly repetitive his writings had become. And others noted that in his otherwise interesting recorded and published interviews and dialogues, Wilber exhibits an annoying tendency to do his guest or interlocutor the “favor” of explaining what he or she really meant by translating what was just said into the jargon of AQAL.

OK, so Wilber is human, imperfect. But the situation is a bit more bleak and serious than outlined so far. If becoming repetitive and jargon-prone were all that seemed to signal that Wilber had exhausted his potential, well that would have been unfortunate enough. Events of just a few years ago indicate that Wilber apparently thinks his work deserves the same kind of respect and attention given to that done by practicing psychologists, philosophers, and scientists. But Wilber and his work are not taken seriously by most professional psychologists, philosophers, and scientists and anyone pointing out this fact to Wilber, however directly or indirectly, formally or informally, risks–as you will see shortly–making Wilber quite cranky.

In a infamous series of blog postings in June 2006, Wilber viciously attacked his critics, including one erstwhile sympathetic reader and follower, Frank Visser. Wilber could not apparently tolerate the close reading and criticism Visser was publishing on his website, Integral World. In the first of these blog posts, “What We Are, That We See,” dated June 8, 2006, Wilber threw Visser and other unnamed critics “under the bus” with language so offensive that it is now highly unlikely Wilber can ever hope to communicate to the size and type of audience he may have once aspired to inform and educate.

Footnotes in works of cultural histories to be written in the coming years, decades, and centuries will likely include references to Wilber, including references to the infamous June 8, 2006 kenwilber.com blog posting just cited. Towards the end of that post, Wilber lets loose with this spooge of angry, figurative prose that no amount of “context” placement can rescue.

It’s gotten to the point that one critic cringes when I simply use the word “simply” (as in the previous paragraph), because it means something horrible is going to follow. In this case, true; the horrible thing that followed was this critic’s charge. But simply still, I simply cannot stand this simple criticism of simply anything, let alone “simply,” so simply suck my dick, whaddaya say?

Well, enough. Wyatt has got to go back to work now, back to the real world of real problems, problems that beg for integral care and consciousness. And thus. Oh, wait a minute, I forgot to include a violent metaphor. Let me think. Let me think really hard. Okay, Wyatt has got to go back to work now, protecting the true and the good and the beautiful, while slaying partial-ass pervs, ripping their eyes out and pissing in their eye-sockets, using his Zen sword of prajna to cut off the heads of critics so staggeringly little that he has to slow down about 10-fold just to see them . . . and then rip their eyes out and piss in their eye-sockets . . .

In subsequent posts Wilber claimed he was just testing his readers. Apparently anyone unable to see humor in Wilber’s fantasy of murdering, “ripping” the eyes from his slain critics’ eye-sockets, and washing away the blood with his piss is “simply” not evolved enough to appreciate or understand his writings or his mission. Many were not amused. See this page posted by Frank Visser at Integral World for more reactions to Wilber’s June 2006 postings, as well as links to more commentary and criticism.

Wilber started off in the 1970s as a popularizer of the then still relatively little known traditions of eastern thought and philosophy, a la Alan Watts. Like Watts he popularized much important, good stuff. But unlike Watts, in the years subsequent to his early work, Wilber often tries to take credit where none is due. And, as we have just seen, when Wilber doesn’t get the credit, approval, and respect he thinks due him and his work, well–look sharp!

Ken Wilber has been referred to as the Einstein of consciousness. As suggested above, his students, admirers, and those who have yet to discover his writings might be better off–less subject to disappointment and delusion–if they would think of Ken Wilber as the Asimov of consciousness, not its Einstein. Wilber and the fate of his work might fare better as well if he would more modestly assess what he has so far or may yet still accomplish. What follows is suggestive of how Wilber might proceed to more effectively communicate and engage his critics.

An interesting, not often noted fact about Wilber is that he was raised a fundamentalist Christian. A comparison between Wilber’s style of communicating with hostile or unsympathetic readers, listeners, and critics, and the contrasting style and approach of another contemporary writer about science–Edward O. Wilson, might be instructive here. Wilson, like Wilber, was raised a fundamentalist Christian. And, also like Wilber, Wilson often writes with the intention of inspiring and exhorting his readers to behave more responsibly on this small, shared, and very fragile planet.

The CreationHow much more effective Wilber might be if he would in the future adopt something like the approach Wilson uses in his recent The Creation: A Call for Help and an Invitation to Visit the Embattled Natural World in the Company of a Biologist (Norton 2006). Wilson opens The Creation with a chapter entitled “Letter to a Southern Baptist Pastor.” He continues to address this same “Pastor” in subsequent chapters. At the beginning of his “letter,” Wilson acknowledges that he has moved on from believing in a literal interpretation of the creation as found in Genesis to instead believing in the theory of evolution. He then proceeds to condemn the narrow, parochial views of fundamentalist Christianity, especially for its teaching–with little justification that makes sense in the 21st century–that unbelievers are condemned to hell for all eternity, the first “trillion trillion years” of which eternity areenough for the universe to expand to its own, entropic death, time enough for countless universes like it to be born, expand, and likewise die away. And that is just the beginning of how long condemned souls will suffer in hell–all for the mistake they made in the choice of religion during the infinitesmally small time they inhabited Earth.

Who’s more likely to be taken seriously here. Both Wilson and Wilber have moved beyond the fundamentalist beliefs of their youth. Both have spent many years thinking and writing about evolution, and both have devoted years of time and effort to spreading the gospel of evolution. But Wilson is the more effective in his reliance on and devotion to the scientific method and the norms of communicating scientific discoveries to not only his colleagues and peers but the public in general.

Wilber’s story isn’t finished yet. Being compared to Asimov is just a small episode in a much larger story that includes all of us.


This article was originally published on April 25, 2008 on my old, no longer existent, “Narrative Oversight” blog. Shortly after I posted it, Frank Visser wrote to ask me for permission to publish it in the blog section of his “Integral World” website. Six years later (today is August 29, 2014) you can still find it published on “Integral World.”

Share
Calendar
June 2018
M T W T F S S
« Oct    
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  
Archives
Politics, Culture, Philosophy
  • Rachel Maddow
  • Frank Schaeffer
  • Roberto Ruiz

This Week in God, 6.23.18As if Attorney General Jeff Sessions weren't dealing with enough troubles, he's now being [...]

Soboroff border special to air Sunday at 7pm on NBCJacob Soboroff, MSNBC correspondent, talks about his reporting from the border this week and his hou [...]

Odd Russian behavior in U.S. seen as part of 2016 active measuresMichael McFaul, former U.S. ambassador to Russia, talks about how Russian spy operations against the [...]

HHS Sec Azar photographed at reunion as border crisis boiled overRachel Maddow Show reporting that as his agency constructed "tent city" facilities to hand [...]

Michael Cohen sends mixed signals as case reaches turning pointEmily Jane Fox, senior reporter for Vanity Fair, talks about the pressures facing Donald Trump confi [...]

Trump foments border policy outrage in cynical political ployMichael Beschloss, NBC News presidential historian, discusses how Donald Trump's fomenting of a [...]

Trump admin struggles to repair migrant families it shatteredEfren Olivares, director of the Texas Civil Rights Project Racial and Economic Justice Program, talk [...]

Friday's Mini-Report, 6.22.18Today's edition of quick hits. [...]

Rachel Maddow 6/22/18Watch the full episode of Friday night's The Rachel Maddow Show. [...]

Those who have Trump's ear tend to look a lot like himWhen Trump sought the perspective of people he considered important in the immigration debate, they [...]

 Vote Common Good Bus Tour, Sept. 6 – Nov. 6. Learn More. How do we make our way back into love, be [...]

I would ask Trump’s evangelical supporters, Was it ever about the children, or was it only about whi [...]

This new leg of my Road Trip took me to the beautiful mountain hamlet of Ouray, Colorado to speak at [...]

If Republicans let Trump roll them by using innocent children as hostages, he will learn the lesson [...]

ICYMI, I appeared this morning on AM Joy on MSNBC with Bishop William Barber and Bishop Michael Curr [...]

If you’ve been following this new leg of my Road Trip, you know I recently travelled to the beautifu [...]

As you may know, I recently spoke at San Juans Summit, a gathering put together by Common Good Chris [...]

I recently spoke at San Juans Summit, a gathering of progressive Christians who want to take back th [...]

If you saw my most recent video, you already know that my good friend Samir Selmanović, the Executiv [...]

Please spend a few minutes to get to know my friend Samir Selmanović. Samir is the Executive Directo [...]

The Philosophy of Christopher NolanEver since I first watched Memento and its fascinating exploration of the philosophical question of [...]

Voltaire - CandideThe philosophical problem of evil—the question of how the existence of unnecessary suffering is poss [...]

Arrow - A Celebration of LoveLife is hard enough as it is. Existence, in many ways, is suffering. Obviously, some have it much wo [...]

If 'Despacito' Were Written by an Evo-Devo BiologistIf you are a geek, you are likely to get excited over things others might find boring, laughable, la [...]

James Baldwin Debates William F. BuckleyJames Baldwin, the great essayist, poet, civil rights activist, writer and orator, would have turned [...]

Genius of the Ancient World - SocratesFew figures have been more important and influential in the history of civilization than the ancient [...]

The PresocraticsAnyone who's ever contemplated Raphael's celebrated painting The School of Athens knows th [...]

President Obama's Farewell AddressAs his presidency sadly comes to an end, President Obama delivered last night what is sure to become [...]

John Berger - Ways of SeeingArt critic John Berger's recent death has left a huge void in the world of art appreciation. Wh [...]

Some Thoughts and Feelings on the Aftermath of the ElectionWhen I saw that anger, hate and bigotry were going to win two nights ago, I had to unplug for a whil [...]

Right Living, Thinking, Etc
  • Two Truths News
  • Natural Living-Healthy Planet

Each Friday, we share three topical longreads in our Weekend Reader newsletter. This week, Lion [...]

Michael Carroll, author of Fearless at Work, gives step-by-step advice on how to deal with a toxic w [...]

By practicing the famous mind training slogans, you can bring profound Buddhist wisdom into your day [...]

Lama Tsutrim Allione teaches you an innovative technique, based on the Tibetan Buddhist principles o [...]

Caring for people who are suffering is a loving, even heroic calling, but it takes a toll. Roshi Joa [...]

The past week has seen an upwelling of outcry from Buddhist communities. The post How Buddhists are [...]

Lindsay Kyte explores East Bay Meditation Center’s focus on respect, safety, and the joy of being se [...]

"It is the kindness of the buddhas to provide us with a complete path, and the preliminary prac [...]

Zen priest Liên Shutt teaches a short meditation to foster compassion for beings in search of refuge [...]

Without compassion, everyone is worse off. Zen teacher Roshi Joan Halifax comments on the Trump admi [...]

(Natural News) By now, everybody knows that TIME Magazine’s “screaming migrant girl” cover photo is [...]

(Natural News) Earlier this week one of the establishment media’s oldest purveyors of fake news and [...]

(Natural News) Women are advised not to take ibuprofen during the first six months of pregnancy. Doi [...]

(Natural News) A well-written story can be compelling, regardless of the form it takes. A good book [...]

(Natural News) Vanillic acid is a polyphenol that, in recent years, has become known for its impress [...]

(Natural News) Various charities and organizations around the world often use different methods of r [...]

(Natural News) When it comes to prepping, it’s important to strike a balance between being disciplin [...]

(Natural News) Studies have been conducted on the effects of fracking on bodies of freshwater, parti [...]

(Natural News) Following a diet full of fresh fruits and vegetables is good for your overall health. [...]

Science News
  • The Universe Today
  • Perimeter Institute
  • Science Daily
  • Sky and Telescope

According to a new study from Johns Hopkins University, Mars' Medusa Fossae region was created [...]

According to a new study by three famed scientists, the Fermi Paradox may have a simple resolution - [...]

In a new study, an astrophysicist proposed how an advanced civilization might survive the inevitable [...]

Hosts: Fraser Cain (universetoday.com / @fcain) Dr. Paul M. Sutter (pmsutter.com / @PaulMattSutter) [...]

A team of international scientists recently conducted a study that indicates that cyanobacteria can [...]

According to a new study from Brown University, it appears Ceres has more organic molecules on its s [...]

The Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO) recently captured an image of an impact crater on Mars that tr [...]

Physicist Dr. Sean Raymond recently created a hypothetical system where 550 planets and 9 Suns orbit [...]

In a series of new studies, a pair of French researchers tackle the question of how many people woul [...]

In a new study, astrophysicist Hector Socas-Navarro proposes searching for aliens by looking for sig [...]

From learners to creators: Perimeter’s ninth PSI class graduates Wednesday Jun 20, 2018Class of 30 s [...]

Elizabeth Gould earns W.B. Pearson MedalTuesday Jun 19, 2018Perimeter PhD graduate earns top honours [...]

Eleven Perimeter researchers awarded NSERC Discovery GrantsTuesday Jun 19, 2018A record number of Pe [...]

Perimeter Outreach builds Californian connectionsTuesday Jun 12, 2018Perimeter’s Educational Outreac [...]

Perimeter scoops four awards at CCAE Prix d’ExcellenceThursday Jun 07, 2018Perimeter lauded at natio [...]

New centre for astroparticle physics launches in CanadaThursday May 10, 2018Perimeter Institute is a [...]

Perimeter researcher elected to Royal SocietyWednesday May 09, 2018Mathematical physicist Kevin Cost [...]

THREE NEW APPOINTMENTS BOLSTER MATHEMATICS, COSMOLOGY AT PERIMETERMonday Apr 09, 2018Cosmologist Wil [...]

EMMY NOETHER FELLOWSHIPS TO EXPAND, SIX NEW FELLOWS ANNOUNCEDWednesday Mar 21, 2018Perimeter’s flags [...]

Perimeter Institute mourns the passing of friend and colleague Stephen HawkingWednesday Mar 14, 2018 [...]

'Stealth' material hides hot objects from infrared eyesInfrared cameras are the heat-sensing eyes that help drones find their targets even in the dead of n [...]

Accurate measurements of sodium intake confirm relationship with mortalityEating foods high in salt is known to contribute to high blood pressure, but does that linear relati [...]

Our intestinal microbiome influences metabolism -- through the immune systemThe innate immune system, our first line of defense against bacterial infection, has a side job that [...]

US oil & gas methane emissions 60 percent higher than estimatedThe US oil and gas industry emits 13 million metric tons of the potent greenhouse gas methane from i [...]

Antarctic ice sheet is melting, but rising bedrock below could slow it downAn international team of researchers has found that the bedrock below the remote West Antarctic Ice [...]

Psychiatric disorders share an underlying genetic basisResearchers explored the genetic connections between brain disorders at a scale far eclipsing previo [...]

Einstein proved right in another galaxyAstronomers have made the most precise test of gravity outside our own solar system. By combining da [...]

A mechanism behind choosing alcohol over healthy rewards is foundChanges in a brain signalling system contribute to the development of alcohol addiction-like behavio [...]

Caffeine from four cups of coffee protects the heart with the help of mitochondriaA new study shows that a caffeine concentration equivalent to four cups of coffee promotes the movem [...]

Nearly 80 exoplanet candidates identified in record timeScientists have analyzed data from K2, the follow-up mission to NASA's Kepler Space Telescope, [...]

Scientists have discovered that a supervolcano likely created a mysterious rock formation on Mars so [...]

The dust storm on Mars that broke out at the end of May is now affecting the skies across the entire [...]

Will Mars soon be hidden under a veil of dust? Let's hope not. We explore the current storm and [...]

  Friday, June 22 • The waxing gibbous Moon this evening shines with bright Jupiter to its lower lef [...]

A recent experiment to better understand the nature of dark matter constrains a possible "fifth [...]

The post Main-Belt Comet 133P/(7968) Elst-Pizarro appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

If you like sunrises and sunsets, look for the green flash, a phenomenon that happens more often tha [...]

The post Draco Galaxy Trio appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

The post The Moon heart appeared first on Sky & Telescope. [...]

Summer star party season has begun - grab your scope or binoculars, pack a sleeping bag, and come an [...]